Love, Lies, and Cherry Pie by Jackie Lau

*** Review ***

In Love, Lies, and Cherry Pie by Jackie Lau, we are introduced to the spirited and somewhat exasperated Emily Hung, a writer and part-time barista who is caught in the crossfire of her mother’s relentless matchmaking efforts. The object of her mother’s obsession? Mark Chan, the seemingly dull, sweater-vest-wearing engineer who Emily has long dismissed. What unfolds is a charming and heartfelt romantic comedy that explores family dynamics, personal growth, and the unpredictable nature of love.

Emily Hung’s life seems perfect on the surface—she’s a published author living in Toronto, a vibrant and multicultural city that Lau paints with vivid authenticity. However, being the last unmarried daughter in her family comes with its own set of pressures, mainly in the form of her mother’s overbearing desire to see her settled down. Emily’s irritation reaches a peak when she’s forced to endure Mark’s company at her sister’s wedding, leading her to concoct a wild plan: a fake relationship with Mark to get her mother off her back.

Mark, who initially appears to be a stereotypical “nice guy” lacking in excitement, reluctantly agrees to the charade. The story then takes us on a delightful journey through various fake dates—from bubble tea shops to cake-decorating classes—that reveal the layers beneath Mark’s reserved exterior. As Emily gets to know him, she discovers that her assumptions were misplaced. Mark is not just a dull engineer but a kind, thoughtful individual with his own dreams and insecurities.

The first half of Love, Lies, and Cherry Pie feels dense and somewhat sluggish, weighed down by Emily’s millennial angst and the meta-narrative of her struggles as a writer. While this adds depth to her character, it also hampers the pacing, making it feel like a slow burn that might test the patience of some readers. However, those who persevere are rewarded with a much more engaging second half, where the chemistry between Emily and Mark starts to sizzle and their relationship blossoms into something genuine.

One of the most charming aspects of the book is its portrayal of family dynamics. Emily’s mother, though meddlesome, is a lovable character whose well-meaning interference is rooted in love. The interactions between Emily and her family are both humorous and heartwarming, adding a rich layer of authenticity to the narrative. Similarly, Mark’s family provides a contrasting yet equally compelling background that shapes his character and motivations.

Mark’s character development, however, feels a bit uneven. His silence and reserved nature are endearing, but it takes a while for him to become a fully fleshed-out character. The decision to only include his point of view towards the end leaves readers wanting more insight into his thoughts and feelings earlier in the story. Despite this, the moments where Mark lets his guard down, such as when he supports Emily during her writing sessions, are some of the most touching and memorable parts of the book.

Lau’s decision to set the story in Toronto is another highlight. The city’s vibrant neighborhoods, diverse food scene, and cultural landmarks are woven into the story, creating a rich tapestry that adds depth to the narrative. As a Canadian author, Lau’s authentic depiction of Toronto stands out in a genre often dominated by American settings, making the book a refreshing read for those familiar with the city.

The book also delves into themes of self-doubt and personal growth. Both Emily and Mark grapple with feelings of inadequacy and the pressure to meet their families’ expectations. Their journey towards self-acceptance and the realization that they are enough just as they are is beautifully portrayed and resonates deeply.

In conclusion, Love, Lies, and Cherry Pie is a delightful rom-com that, despite a slow start, delivers a satisfying and heartwarming story. Fans of Bridget Jones, My Big Fat Greek Wedding, and Kim’s Convenience will find much to love in this tale of fake dating, family meddling, and unexpected romance. While the characters and plot might not break new ground in the genre, the book’s charm lies in its authenticity, relatable themes, and the sweet, gradual development of Emily and Mark’s relationship. Jackie Lau’s vivid depiction of Toronto and her heartfelt storytelling make this a book worth picking up for a cozy, feel-good read.